Drudge Retort: The Other Side of the News
Tuesday, November 07, 2017

A hundred years ago, while World War I was raging and no one knew which side would win, the British government, led by Prime Minister David Lloyd George, released a declaration bearing the name of Arthur Balfour, the foreign secretary. This "Balfour Declaration" promised to support "the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people," so long as that did not "prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities" there. That short document (its crucial paragraph contains 67 words) laid the foundation of modern Israel -- but also sowed dragon's teeth.




Why did the British government do it? Some historians argue that a few cabinet ministers sympathized with the Jews and wanted to help them. Others point out that Lloyd George and Balfour were Christian Zionists, who wanted to facilitate the gathering of Jews in Palestine, a precondition, they believed, for the Second Coming. Still others note Palestine's strategic importance: it overlooks Egypt, through which runs the Suez Canal, the United Kingdom's economic jugular at the time, and the cabinet wanted a grateful and largely European population to provide stability if the British established a protectorate there. Moreover, as yet other historians have noted, Foreign Office mandarins pushed Lloyd George and Balfour to act because they feared that if they did not, Germany would, thereby depriving the United Kingdom of Jewish support.

Each of these arguments is true, and the last one points to the most important reason of all. Lloyd George's government issued the Balfour Declaration primarily because it thought that doing so would help it win the war. Most of its members believed that "world Jewry" had great subterranean influence -- over world finance, for example, and, contradictorily, over world socialism. They thought that American Jewish financiers could persuade U.S. President Woodrow Wilson to bring his country into World War I. They thought that Russian Jewish socialists could persuade Russian Prime Minister Aleksandr Kerensky not to leave it. And they thought that the way to win over these disparate Jews was to promise them Palestine.

They believed all of this because the most important Zionist in the United Kingdom, Chaim Weizmann, had convinced them of it.


Admin's note: Participants in this discussion must follow the site's moderation policy. Profanity will be filtered. Abusive conduct is not allowed.

"The document took so long to produce, however, and the process of its production was so tortuous, that it had unanticipated results. First of all, by the time it was released, the United States had already entered the war, and Russia was irrevocably on the way out. Contrary to the wishes of those who framed it, the Balfour Declaration did not influence the outcome of World War I. But surely it influenced what happened after."

During the war, the British government had been attempting to win over the Zionists with one hand, while coaxing Arabs into serving its interests with the other. It successfully encouraged Husayn ibn Ali, the sharif of Mecca, to rebel against their common enemy, the Ottoman Empire. When the sharif launched his insurrection, he did so believing that the United Kingdom had promised to support the establishment of an independent Arab kingdom, including Palestine, of which he would be the leader -- not a home in Palestine for the Jewish people. He therefore viewed the Balfour Declaration as a great betrayal. After November 2, 1917, neither he nor his followers would trust "perfidious Albion."

Nor would many Zionists (although Weizmann remained an Anglophile all his life). This is because they had discovered that even as the British government was promising Palestine to them, it was bound by the Sykes-Picot agreement of 1916 to cede the north of the country to France and the holy cities to government by international condominium. Of course, Zionists did not view the Balfour Declaration as a betrayal, but they knew now that the British government was capable of forsaking them.

What they never learned was that Lloyd George had been prepared to betray them even as they celebrated the declaration he made possible. In January 1918, mere weeks after issuing it, he had sent an emissary to speak with the Turks about a separate peace. Having Turkey out of the war would be a greater contribution to an Allied victory than anything concerning Jews and Arabs. Lloyd George offered the Turks various inducements. One was that if the Ottomans deserted Germany, their flag could continue to fly over Palestine. Had they accepted this offer, no one would be referring to the Balfour Declaration today.

#1 | Posted by Doc_Sarvis at 2017-11-06 07:21 AM | Reply

link please. meanwhile... have another, www.haaretz.com

#2 | Posted by ichiro at 2017-11-06 01:36 PM | Reply

the link

#3 | Posted by ichiro at 2017-11-06 01:37 PM | Reply

@ichiro both links require registration which is a non starter for me.
Do you have a specific objection to what was posted?
The Balfour Declaration promised two incompatible goals a Jewish homeland without prejudicing the rights of the pre-existing non-Jewish residents.
The first succeeded, but at the expense of the second.
Much of the conflicts which still exist today can be laid at the feet of British Foreign Secretaries, Pakistan/India over Kashmir, the Kurds, & certainly not least the Palestinians & Israelis.

#4 | Posted by kingcuke at 2017-11-07 08:41 AM | Reply

The British were masters at divide and conquer. If they lacked opposing factions to play against one another, would import a new faction. Did it in Northern Ireland too.

#5 | Posted by Sully at 2017-11-07 10:10 AM | Reply

What does the Middle East have?

How can we get at it?

Follow the money - that's all you need to do.

All other issues are secondary.

If it doesn't work out - Have a war.

#6 | Posted by Pegasus at 2017-11-07 03:02 PM | Reply

Comments are closed for this entry.

Home | Breaking News | Comments | User Blogs | Stats | Back Page | RSS Feed | RSS Spec | DMCA Compliance | Privacy | Copyright 2018 World Readable

Drudge Retort