Drudge Retort: Red Meat for Yellow Dogs
Sunday, September 21, 2008

A former Army Special Forces commander who underwent a sex change operation was discriminated against by the U.S. government, a federal judge ruled Friday. The Library of Congress backed out of a 2005 job offer to Diane Schroer after being told of her intention to become a transsexual. At the time of the job interview for a position as a senior terrorism research analyst, she was a male.

Liberal Blog Advertising Network

Menu

Subscriptions

Author Info

rcade

MORE STORIES

Special Features

Comments

Admin's note: Participants in the discussion of this weblog entry should note the site's moderation policy.

Still thinking.... wish to see him and her -- any photos?

Did she win a suit?

Or did she settle for a skirt?

A victory for transsexuals!
Finally.

Discrimination is always wrong. Always.
- Mahatma Ghandi

Obama will have transsexuals in his cabinet.
Praise his diversity.
Praise his inclusion.
Give Obama a chance.
Give peace a chance.

Be Well.

Why anyone needs to chop up their genitals in order to feel whole has a tragic problem. That such a surgical procedure is available is contrary to a healthy enjoyment of one's own sexual gratification. There is simply no way an artificial cock or pussy will ever provide the same lubricatory function and nerve excitation. Giving up that to be another sex is tragic.

A Government that panders to this excess is on a path to bankruptcy. Not because they were discriminatory, but because they waste time in Court fighting about it.

Nutcase wants to bang a tranny
Nutcase wants to bang a tranny
Or is it that you want the tranny to bang you?

Yeah well Ghandi ALSO said

"Clause 200 makes provision for registration of persons belonging to uncivilized races, resident and employed within the Borough. One can understand the necessity of registration of Kaffirs who will not work, but why should registration be required for indentured Indians who have become free, and for their descendants about whom the general complaint is that they work too much?"

- Mahatma Ghandi

So how about we not use him as a source of wisdom about discriminatory practices?

Or, if that one wasn't obvious enough for you:

""You say that the magistrate's decision is unsatisfactory because it would enable a person, however unclean, to travel by a tram, and that even the Kaffirs would be able to do so. But the magistrate's decision is quite different. The Court declared that the Kaffirs have no legal right to travel by tram. And according to tram regulations, those in an unclean dress or in a drunken state are prohibited from boarding a tram. _Thanks to the Court's decision, only clean Indians or colored people other than Kaffirs, can now travel in the trams._""

Underscores for emphasis mine.

He was this close and had it snatched away!

That said, bravo. I have my doubts that a "senior terrorism research analyst" actually goes in front of cameras very often, so who cares if she looks a little weird during the transition time. If you can't discriminate against someone for looking a little brown, then you can't discriminate against someone for looking a little gender-ambiguous.

That's just fair and equal.

Doesn't matter, many still believe the justice system is an abomination.

SOHEIFOX,

I wasn't aware that to serve as an example of wisdom and good behaviour you had to emerge from the womb perfectly saintly. Those comments were made in his capacity as a lawyer when he was younger. People learn things as they get older and experience more. Later, he would do much to help these same Kaffirs, some say too much, including supporting their desire to break away and form their own nation because they refused to be civil citizens in a secular nation, and insisted that living in anything other than an Islamic country was an affront.

I hope you didn't forget that Lincoln was a vile racist for much of his adult life; shall we consider all of his accomplishments as hopelessly tainted as well?

Transsexual Wins Suit Against Library of Congress

How did it win the suit? With a full house or three of a kind. Did it get a nice pin stripe with skirt or pants? I'm afraid to read the article

"He was this close and had it snatched away!" - KEITH

FF for KEITH.

I hope you didn't forget that Lincoln was a vile racist for much of his adult life; shall we consider all of his accomplishments as hopelessly tainted as well?

#11 | Posted by Straink at 2008-09-21 02:26 PM | Reply | Flag:

I was actually trying to tie this back unsuccessfully to something else entirely. No, I don't think that people cannot change and should be damned forever for things that happened when they were young. I realize on rereading there's no way to follow what I was saying where I wanted it to go, so I'll just have to withdraw the entire thing.

"so I'll just have to withdraw the entire thing."

That's what he-she said.

***** Obama will have transsexuals in his cabinet.
...... Posted by skip_wellington *******

.....is he planning on a non-partisan cabinet that includes Republicans ?......

.......George Bush had the first Gay/Straight administration that was mainly gay..perhaps it is time for all orientations to be represented.......

......"Hey Mary...Mary Cheney...get the cigar out of your mouth and bring the girls another round "......"...and don't smoke those cigars...don't you know where they've been ?"..

Mary : " That's why I'm smoking them "......

"...Why anyone needs to chop up their genitals in order to feel whole has a tragic problem....A Government that panders to this excess is on a path to bankruptcy...Posted by nutcase

Please post a link to your Dual Doctorate Degree in Human Psychosexual Developement and Political History.

Otherwise, shut-the-fuck-up!

Your opinion counts about as much as a cockroach.


I didn't know Mary Cheney was in the Bush cabinet. The things I learn here on drudge.


**** I didn't know Mary Cheney was in the Bush cabinet. The things I learn here on drudge.

...... Posted by Sniper *****

......read my post again......I said "administration"...Bush had the first queer/mafia administration in American history......probably because he is gay himself....

.......but if you want to restrict talk to cabinet queers, we all know Bush himself is queer, and Condi Rice is a lesbian.......

I just want to say that STRAINK's post is a breath of sanity among some of you pitiful creatures on this thread.

... a man named David intended to become, legally, culturally and physically, a woman named Diane ...

The presentation of the situation of this person wreaks of an unwillingness to address the problem.

There is a man, who was suffering from such distress that he arranged for his physical mutilation, and then protended after he was mutiliated, that somehow there had been a gender transformation. A citation:

The surgery itself consists of removal of the testicles, dissecting the penis to remove all erectile tissue and release the urethra (urine outlet), and inversion of the penile skin to form a vaginal cavity. If there is insufficient penile skin, skin from the scrotum can be used, although it's less satisfactory; skin grafts from other parts of the body may also be used.

There are some pictures of the procedure here; www.transgenderzone.com but DON'T look at them if pictures of surgical procedures upset you.


A person so distraught as to voluntarily undergo this procedure is to be pitied rather than scorned. But surprise, "He" is not a woman. No matter how many times he may repeat the "transformation mantra," he is not converted into "a woman." He remains a mutilated male.

By the way, what's a "special forces commander?" Commander" is a naval rank equivalent to as I recall, O-5, the equivalent of a Lt. Col. in the Army or Air Force. Since the rank wasn't capitalized, I suspect that the man was not a Commander, but possibly was an officer of sorts with a lower rank, even quite possibly a non-com. The writer of the article is seemingly unfamiliar with military ranks. But what's new, these journalism types are generally ignoramuses. I wonder what the writer intended to convey by referring to the subject of the article as a "special forces 'commander'"?

Here's a link to a photo of "the convert," and an elaborated article. transgriot.blogspot.com

The term "convert" is appropriate since the courts reasoning as set forth in the cited article.

The court compares the discrimination faced by Schroer to religious-based discrimination, saying, "Imagine that an employee is fired because she converts from Christianity to Judaism. Imagine too that her employer testified that he harbors no bias toward either Christians or Jews but only 'converts.' That would be a clear case of discrimination 'because of religion.' No court would take seriously the notion that 'converts' are not covered by the statute."

The Court extended the application of Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act to include a class not protected under the act. But what's new. Judicial tyranny and usurpation of power from the other branches of government is de rigeur nowadays, and has been for decades.

idiotic ruling.. no one should have to hire nutcases.. mutilate your privates and cross dress.. guess what.. most people are going to think you're nuts..

comes with the territory..

idiotic ruling.. no one should have to hire nutcases.. mutilate your privates and cross dress.. guess what.. most people are going to think you're nuts..

comes with the territory..

The Library of Congress has a history of discrimination, including losing a class action lawsuit. The case was just ridiculous. Offering her the position, then rescinding the offer based solely on sex change. The hiring official didn't even bother to find out if such a change would affect her perception by those she would be working with in Congress. It doesn't help that she was super qualified for the position. The result in this case was exactly right, and hopefully they will have to pay some big money.

When I worked for a certain government agency my specialty required us to go for training at a certain National location several times annualy. A former man who had a sex change operation to become a woman was sent there many times for training. "She" must have been a bad looking man to begin with and then became a real nasty looking woman, bald head and all. When "she" would get on the elevator everyone would get off. "She" filed EEO complaints because no one would sit next to "her" in class or work with her in the lab. Anyway, a rumour started that "she" had a crush on one of the guys from my office. We never let him live it down to this day. Such was life in the wild and wacky world of political correctness.

Why anyone needs to chop up their genitals in order to feel whole has a tragic problem

~Nutcase

Some people are just born in the wrong bodies.

If gender reassignment surgery makes them feel like the person they were born to be then go ahead sez Spud.

Be Well.

"When "she" would get on the elevator everyone would get off."

About what I would expect from a hate filled POS.

Danni,

It has nothing to do with hate.


Apparently, "she" had a propensity for ripping paint-peeling farts in elevators. Some of the farts she'd uncork would singe your mustache! You'd vacate the elevator too, if you saw her coming in.

when did "heterosexual" transexuals skip over homosexuals in the heirarchy of society?

makes me laugh that we can get this ruling and still not recognize gay marriages.

still a good ruling though.

If a person is male and has surgery they do not become "female". They are still a male. This has something to do with genetics, I think. The designation of this person as "she" is biologically wrong.

Of course you could go by the liberal hack ideology that you should refer to a person the way they want to be referred to otherwise you might hurt their self esteem.

way to contribute there, FK.

"way to contribute there, FK."

Posted by Hagbard_Celine

Thanks, I'm glad you agree!

"Of course you could go by the liberal hack ideology that you should refer to a person the way they want to be referred to otherwise you might hurt their self esteem."

Or you could try your best to make them feel unwelcome and reviled because they don't fit into your narrow view of what is acceptable. I have noticed throughout my life that those with the least tolerance for difference coincidentally happened to be assholes.
The less judgemental folks seem to be more confident, more intelligent and actually just better people.

"The less judgemental folks seem to be more confident, more intelligent and actually just better people."

Posted by danni

I know many people who are judgmental and very intelligent and many very "tolerant" ones who are very stupid. So, your theory becomes just your opinion. But your theory does show your arrogance!

My opinion is that surgical mutilation does change ones sex.

Correction: My opinion is that surgical mutilation does NOT change ones sex.

DANNI says that we should be "less judgemental" and then goes on to judge a whole group of people.
That type of liberal circular thinking collapses and falls back on itself.

Transexualism is a form of mental illness and should be treated by a psychiatrist not a surgeon.
If a person thinks they are a chicken do you implant feathers into their body so they feel better? If a person thinks they are an elephant do you attach ...er...ah...floppy ears...uh sorry to insult your candidate.

We are all "judgemental" and it is a good thing. We judge who will be our friends and spouses and where we work and live. We judge what kind of car we drive and even which of many grapefruits to choose from. Judgement is an important part of being human. I am proud to be a real human being instead of a crazy lib.

"If a person thinks they are an elephant do you attach ...er...ah...floppy ears...uh sorry to insult your candidate."

Posted by fwthom

The mental image you brought with that will have me laughing all day!!!!!!!

#35 | Posted by danni at 2008-09-22 09:33 AM

The less judgemental folks seem to be more confident, more intelligent and actually just better people.

Danni displays the usual leftist humility in evaluating her views and comparing them to those of others. And these folks don't recognize how structured and constrained their views are.

"Danni displays the usual leftist humility in evaluating her views and comparing them to those of others. And these folks don't recognize how structured and constrained their views are."

Be kind to Danni. She's about three clowns short of a circus and by this time of day, she's had a couple of hours on that bong of hers. Consequently, there are a load of things she doesn't recognize. Be PC...show some pity.

Transexualism is a form of mental illness and should be treated by a psychiatrist not a surgeon.

Then this case was definitely correctly decided. You cannot discriminate in hiring based on a disability.

"You cannot discriminate in hiring based on a disability."

Posted by bperk

You can if the diability is stupidity.

If a person thinks they are an elephant do you attach ...er...ah...floppy ears...uh sorry to insult your candidate.

#38 | Posted by fwthom

There was an episode of South Park that dealt with that question.... but it was a man who believed he was a dolphin in that case.

www.jibjab.com

en.wikipedia.org

"Transexualism is a form of mental illness and should be treated by a psychiatrist not a surgeon."

Generally speaking transsexualism, also known as gender disphoria, is treated by a psychiatrist for quite some time before any surgery is suggested. I know a few transsexual folks, to call them mentally ill is ridiculous. They are actually very well adjusted, contributing members of society who would be welcome in my home any time while some of the irrational haters who post here would not be. Some folks need to understand the phrase "live and let live." Those who can't reveal more about themselves than anything else when they express such vile thoughts about people they know absolutely nothing about.

I have noticed throughout my life that those with the least tolerance for difference coincidentally happened to be assholes.

Agreed, Danni. And might I add that it is a non-partisan trait.

Some people are just born in the wrong bodies.


If gender reassignment surgery makes them feel like the person they were born to be then go ahead sez Spud.


Be Well.


#28 | Posted by dethspud

You have been listening to your shrink too much me thinks spudster. Talk with HERM - this guy should have been aborted.

You libs can find a reason to excuse any behavior. Amazing. Some psycho wants to wack off his genitals and you think he was born in the wrong body. Sounds like a buffbob issue. Or scientologist.

By the way, there was a show on Sat night about 2 men (they did not know each other.. different parts of the country) who each decided they wanted to go through the process of being transformed into women. Went through the whole year living as women, etc, through all the therapy and prep, and then started the chemical and, in one case, underwent the physical surgery involved.

After living with the change for some time, then they both decided that they had changed their minds and had to undergo the process of reversal... at least to the extent possible. Now that's a tragic situation.

I cannot recall the channel (maybe MSNBC) or the title, even though they both seemed ok with where they ended up by the end of the program, it was pretty depressing to watch the whole thing play out.

The mental image you brought with that will have me laughing all day!!!!!!!

#40 | Posted by FreddyK


The hills are alive with the sound of nazis laughing.

What has me laughing is that you right wing assholes are the first ones to be bent over a toilet stall doing a little tappity-tap whenever you've had 2 beers (and jesus ain't looking).

Lipz did you ever hear of "projection" upon others of feelings that are your own? Hmm.


If a person thinks they are an elephant do you attach ...


OK, so that unfortunately reminds me of this oldie:

"A guy loses his member in an unfortunate accident. Goes to doctor. Doctor says he can do the up-town surgery for $25K, or the low-end surgery for $500. Guy picks $500 surgery, which involves sewing the end of an elephant trunk onto where the member once was. Doctor assures him it is ok. Guy recuperates, goes on his first date with a woman since the operation. At dinner in a fancy restaurant, while they're eating, much to the guy's dismay, the trunk works its way out and grabs a dinner roll out of the bread basket on the table and disappears back under the table. Woman thinks she saw it, but not sure, can't believe her eyes. Few minutes later, same thing. Now she's sure. "Did I just see what I think I saw?" "Yes" "Can you make it do it again?" Well, I could try but I'm not sure my ass can handle another hard roll."

Click here for the obligatory rim shot: instantrimshot.com

If I have offended any elephants or bakers, I sincerely apologize.

"The hills are alive with the sound of nazis laughing."

Posted by Lipzoidial

He was making fun of your candidate's ears. When does that make someone a Nazi? I have read you and many others here make fun of the looks of many rebublicans. So are you a Nazi?

He was making fun of your candidate's ears. When does that make someone a Nazi?

Don't let it get you down, Freddy. Lipzoidial is one of the most prolific examples of Godwin's Law in action on this site.

Comments are closed for this entry.

Drudge Retort

Home | News | Comments | User Blogs | Nooner | Back Page | RSS Feed | RSS Spec | Copyright 2009 World Readable