Woke,
what bugged me about the incident Murtha made an issue of wasn't that it was something we should ignore or not call it what it was. It was a horrible incident and we were at fault.
But the global media spectacle that ensued after Murtha's extremely public comments did nothing to help our soldiers IMO.
In fact, I would argue that things got harder for them. Certainly the incident needed to be addressed but couldn't it have been done more discretely?
I'm sure I will get lambasted for this but, IMO, I still maintain Murtha did that for political partisan reasons and not for the good of our soldiers.
#242 | POSTED BY EBERLY AT 2010-02-09 12:43 PM
1st: Thanks for the civil comment. It is always appreciated.
2nd: We disagree that hiding these kinds of incidents and pretending they didn't occur is better for our troops and country. I disagree with Obama on that also, though i support his decision to not show more abu photos while our troops are still in harm's way, especially since some have already been shown.
What happens when these incidents do surface, despite the attempts to hide them? Credibility lost along with moral high ground, eh?
3rd: The backlash of Murtha's truthful comments about Haditha did not help him politically and surely you can see that. Think of the price he paid for speaking truth. Same as Kerry has paid for reporting what 100 other Vietnam vets said at Winter Soldier. Same as the backlash I get here at DR and other blogs for daring to be a war vet who questions our govt and military.
4th: The M.O. when these incidents occur is to:
1. stonewall and cover up.
2. deny until proven
3. once proven, offer up 1 or 2 low level troops to be punished as was done with MeLai and Abu....while ignoring the policies that come from above
This is why Winter Soldier happened. We returning war vets were outraged that Lt. Calley was made a scapegoat for an incident that was unwritten US military policy in VN....."free fire zones" and "search and destroy" missions that included civilians.
Wonder when hallichainy will be prosecuted for his lies that placed our troops in harm's way in iraqnam and for supporting/directing torture interrogations??
As for the "global media", try looking at what O'Reilly, Cavuto, Beck, Malkin, et al did with Murtha's truthful statement. They generalized it, lied about what was said, then used it to skewer him from their media pulpets......
mediamatters.org
So, was it Murtha's fault that the rw media used his comments for political gain?
Was it not Murtha's job to oversee this incident?
Is it not our reps job to report to us?
I don't think Murtha damaged the corps.
The people who stoplossed our troops, sent them into an unnecessary occupation on repeated deployments and thereby helped create the incident which created the harm to the corps and the US.
Have a nice day. Back to snow shovelling for me.