POSTED BY HOPE4HOPE AT 11:00 AM | 27 COMMENTS | PERMALINK | COMMENT ON THIS ENTRY
Well written post.
Pay no attention to these swine.
#1 | POSTED BY DIABLO AT 2009-10-19 11:16 AM | REPLY | FLAG:
#2 | POSTED BY KBM AT 2009-10-19 11:52 AM | REPLY | FLAG
3 | POSTED BY ATAXPAYER AT 2009-10-19 11:59 AM | REPLY | FLAG:
as to this..
Yes we would. There is noting to "win" there. There is no single government to defeat. There is no single enemy to fight. Russia learned that the hard way. Seems we weren't paying attention.
#23 | POSTED BY KANREI AT 2009-10-19 04:08 PM | REPLY | FLAG:
There was a clear goal in the beginning.. I would suggest you read "First In" or "Jawbreaker"
Our first teams of CIA/Seal operatives on the ground did a real number on the Taliban forces and had we pressed them once they were cornered in the mountains in Tora Bora with all of our concentrated strength they would not have wiggled free.
However, we did not do that, so we are stuck in the same rotten situation that the soviets found themselves, albeit for different reasons.
right now, the real trick to Afghanistan is redevelopment, stability of government and putting people to work that are currently making a living toting a rifle around.
The only way to make that happen is to engage with the individual tribal leaders and get them on our side. Without getting taken for a ride by any of them.
Terorism needs to be dealt with as a Law Enforcement problem Not a Military problem.
The military is not an investigative body. They are not designed to root out conspirators.
Asking infantry Captains and Lieutenants (avg age 25 to 35) to Investigate this stuff is silly. These guys were trained to lead teams of men to fight other teams of men and make them dead. Not to get to the bottom of a crime.
The best people we have for that job are our Anti-Organised crime folks in the FBI, the way Afghanistan works is so close to the way Sicily or La Cosa Nostra here works its astonishing.
Family patriarchs who run substantial parts of the country unfettered by the government
Family feuds that are on par with low level war.
What we need here is not General whoever.
What we need here is another Sammy Gravano to rat em all out.
No one ever thought they would get an Underboss of one of the Five families to turn states evidence.
If enough pressure is placed on these Criminals, they will be caught, and dealt with.
By giving them our military to fight, we give them Airs, that they are Soldiers fighting the Infidel.
Thats horseshit.
They are garden variety thugs and should be treated as such.
And before you bring up Suicide Bombers.. do me a favor.
Think about what you are going to say first...
do you really think the guys Planning and Recruiting for (the guys we need to capture and imprison) terrorist attacks are the ones actually blowing themselves up?
no.. the poor saps they get to do that are nobodies.
Which is why they are so hard to stop.
And even so, stopping them has the same effect on the overall structure as stopping a 20 year old kid who works for the Gambinos that is knocking over a Liquor store or selling heroin on a street corner.. Its a tactical victory yes, but meaningless in the grand scheme.
Cut off the heads of these organizations like Hercules and the Hydra, Eventually they will wither and die.