Drudge Retort: Red Meat for Yellow Dogs
Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Chris Hedges: As we sink into an economic and political morass, as we barrel toward a crisis that will create more misery than the Great Depression, we are controlled, manipulated and distracted by the celluloid shadows on the wall of Plato's cave. The fantasy of celebrity culture is not designed simply to entertain. It is designed to drain us emotionally, confuse us about our identity, make us blame ourselves for our predicament, condition us to chase illusions of fame and happiness and keep us from fighting back ... another tawdry and tasteless spectacle to divert a dying culture from the howling wolf at the gate.

Liberal Blog Advertising Network

Menu

Subscriptions

Author Info

zarathustra

MORE STORIES

Special Features

Comments

Admin's note: Participants in the discussion of this weblog entry should note the site's moderation policy.

take you no idols.

A great article by Chris Hedges dissecting the mass psychology of a culture that produces, promotes, (sometimes) destroys, but always obsesses over celebrity status.

I've always wondered why certain people spend so much time following their favorite celebrity's every move. Chances are, the aforementioned movie star/singer/model/etc. wouldn't be caught dead with most of their fans, yet the obsession continues. Where did Britney Spears go for vacation? Whose label is printed on Brad Pitt's t-shirt? What's the name of the nightclub where Paris Hilton got drunk last night?

Hedges makes a convincing argument that the culture of Wall Street is responsible our current national zeitgeist - wealth, fame, and beauty ueber alles - and that this is the source of our cultural pathology.

Um, not all of us care about "celebrities".

"You're blind, baby.
You're blind to the facts of who you are
Because you're watchin' that garbage."

Chuck D, "Planet Zero"

This article reminds me of a doctor looking at a particularly disquisting growth and describing it in medical terms. Like this, 'The wild pursuit of status, wealth and fame'.

What is it all saying, really? Haven't there always been those who sought wealth, power and fame to the exclusion of all else?

It's also enticing to try to say that TV and the Internet caused our latest infection. But we were already sick long before they came along.

How can one live a life of zen when every form of communication is telling you what to see, hear or think? And it's telling you to be all you can be, be strong, go forward, move ahead, climb the mountain, get the girl, love the lord, buy radial tires, and then you'll be happy. And it never works.

And no one, I mean no one just stops and says, 'Who am I?'. 'What do I believe'? If you do that, you will be immune to about 90% of the neurotic gossip that goes on in the social/government/
entertainment industry.

It says nothing about me. I've watched none of it. Is he still dead?

Not only is he dead... He's been murdered!

'Who am I?'. 'What do I believe'?

those questions are asked and all to often the answer is I dont know.

But Hulkamaniacs who believe in a higher power, donate their time, money, and sweat to help the poor, and live modest, moral lives are routinely trashed by Loony Lefties as being "Religious Nuts."

It's pretty easy to look down your nose at other people and scold them.

HULKAMANIA FOREVER

I've always wondered why certain people spend so much time following their favorite celebrity's every move.

#2 | Posted by Zarathustra

It's kind of like following your favorite blog.

Wow. Best piece I've read all year. While I thankfully missed the TV coverage of it all, I know Hedges is right. He nailed it, not so much focusing on the MJ coverage, but on what it means to us as a country right now. The last line says it all. We have become the ultimate nihlists as a country. Not just celebrity worship either. One side is trying to fit two square pegs into one small round hole and the other side is going through an enraged completely unpatriotic hissy fit...to the point of wishing everything goes to hell to make them look better, even though they started the mess in the first place.

Basically everything sucks right now and that has created a culture in and of itself.

Not everyone buys into that pop culture cable tv talking head bunk, chuckles.

I could care less about celebrities too. But that hasn't kept everything in this country from going to hell in a handbasket. The culture of celebrity destruction, I believe like Hedges, is only a figurehead, a window into the bigger cultural issues that I and most everyone do care about.

"I could care less about celebrities too.
Posted by bocaink"

You could? Not me.

LetUsPrey is pretty defensive about this topic.

I don't know, it got us away from thinking about the worst recession since the great depression in the words of many dem during the campaign. Funny, after the election you don't here them saying how bad our economy is.

I don't worship him, but Michael did make "Thriller," did he not? Shame on all of those who've been influenced or incited to dance by his music, who were a little saddened by the news? This guy Hedges is a sourpuss.

just check the obamaites

This guy Hedges is a sourpuss.

#17 | Posted by Scrumplet

Its one thing to remember him for his musical talent but two weeks of non-stop coverage? And it ain't over yet.

wow this guy is just about as good as dr phil and oprah.

#10 - funny flag for Petrous

Bread and circuses, mofo.

Not everyone buys into that pop culture cable tv talking head bunk, chuckles.

#12 | Posted by LetUsPrey

I wish all people rejected the bullshit celebrity hype. Unfortunately, the tabloid media is extremely successful.

At the checkout line in the grocery store, I never cease to be amazed by how many different publications are dedicated to the lives of celebrities.

I absolutely detest this, but it's an unfortunate byproduct of our weird culture. It's a burgeoning industry for a reason - average joe/jane seeks out stories about the rich and famous to vicariously experience the trials and tribulations of others...instead of dealing with what's happening in their own lives. Weird.

Whether or not they lived a "tragic/heroic/insert-
adjective-here" life, died early, etc., "celebrities" get far too much attention from the media and their lapdogs.

I think Hedges makes some excellent points about the origins of our cultural values, and the damage they have done.

"I could care less about celebrities too.
Posted by bocaink"

You could? Not me.

#14 | Posted by mOntecOre

Ah yes...someone who is still alive to the use of precise language!

A reference to the caring continuum, I presume?

What an utter crock of shit.

The cult of celebrity goes back to caveman days.

What do you think was going on in Roman times, Proconsuls went off to war for the power created by the celebrity status. It finally reached its pinnacle with Caesar becoming a king and a god.

This is not an invention of our times. This is the eternal yearning of the ego, both of the celebrity, and of the rest of us who watch in infatuation and jealousy those who are more famous, more beautiful.

Tale as old as time

I've never seen the caring continuum, but I agree with it.

#19

I guess I haven't really been plugged in to the mainstream news lately. I do notice all the magazine and tabloid covers, and all the music being played (which I don't mind). I don't have a TV yet, maybe I shouldn't even get one. Plenty of books to read.

Tale as old as time

#25 | Posted by boojiboy

Of course, the individual's pursuit of bigger and better things is not new...

But, neither is the tendency for groups/ideologies to self-aggrandize.

Although the ultimate goal is not new or unique, I don't think it's fair to dismiss this story outright.

If you do discount the story as a "crock of shit", however, then I suppose there's also no use in getting upset at the latest Democratic/Republican consolidation of power, or use of dishonest means to attain privilege and power, etc..right?

Relentless Jackson coverage says more about the media than anything else.

It's an easy story.

Reporters are lazy.

"Relentless Jackson coverage says more about the media than anything else.

It's an easy story.

Reporters are lazy."

Oh, my God.

I'm in complete agreement with Vernon.

Must. Lie. Down.

america is the michael jackson of the world -
borrowing from friend and frenemy alike, blowing that $ on materialistic frivolity and appearance instead of investing it in the future, questionable yet legal activities involving innocents, and still somehow maintaining the ubiquitous 'star status' of which others only dream.
hedges is right, there is much metaphor in these celebrity proceedings for everything that is wrong and right with america (and humanity in general). i haven't paid ANY attention to the televised hoohah regarding jackson's death, but between word of mouth, the print and e-media, and biographical research, an unflattering picture begins to emerge of a man who knew where his destiny was to take him (even telling his then-wife lisa marie presley that he'd end up just like' her dad)... and here lies the most potent metaphor for america... knowing that the wrong course is being held with rigidity, but CHOOSING not to steer away from oblivion.
i hope we can do better, or else risk an early death just the same.
be well, and kill your tv.

#29

Tis true. Sure there are quite a few slackoffs in our society, always will be. But I keep reading and hearing lamentations about how we're lost causes wasting ourselves away. That same old crybaby shit's getting stale.

That same old crybaby shit's getting stale.

#32 | Posted by Scrumplet

A society laboring to support the slackers is a tale as old a recorded history itself.

Maybe "the same old crybaby shit" would indeed be "stale" if we (USA) weren't sliding down the rankings in terms of education, healthcare, economic productivity, etc...

A whole lot of people in this country are lost causes, wasting themselves away on tabloid tales of Britney Spears and Michael Jackson...that, or they're preoccupied with their favorite competitor on American Idol, frittering away their lives on MySpace/Facebook/Youtube, etc...

America is quickly sliding down the international pecking order. I'm not old enough to have witnessed firsthand the zenith of the American way of life, but it's clear to anyone not living in a cave that that way of life is quickly coming to an end...what we experience today most certainly does not represent the "End of History" (apologies to Francis Fukuyama...)

#29 and #30
Investigative reporting is expensive so we get less and less of it over time. Its got more to do with a competetive bottom line than with lazy reporters. These stories run because editors approve them don't forget. We're also to blame as we eat this shit up.

Work, consume, watch television, and shut the fuck up bitches!

You also have to remember that news divisions on tv networks were historically allowed to be money losers because they had a higher goal than profit. Thse days are over. Now their main purpose is the same as any sitcom or game show, i.e. to attract eyes to increase advertising dollars.

And add to that the FOX news affiliate setting the legal precedent that a news org is under no legal obligation to tell the truth, and here we are.

Tale as old as time

Very true. It is Greek tragedy. A person of high standing or prosperity with a tragic flaw loses all.

We have never lost our fascination with it.

Its got more to do with a competetive bottom line than with lazy reporters. These stories run because editors approve them don't forget.

#34 | Posted by Hagbard_Celine at 2009-07-15 08:46 PM | Reply | Flag:

Sorry to poke your balloon, but I worked in the media for a number of years. Newspapers and radio mostly, and the fact is that most reporters are quite lazy.

I used to get more than 50 press releases a day, written by PR flacks. The next day they would show up -- word for word -- in a competing paper under some 'reporter's' byline.

TV and radio were the same.

Editors are no longer the Lou Grant types (I was that kind of editor). They have a hole to fill, and they fill it with whatever the reporter turns in.

You were like Lou Grant Vernon??

You know, underneath that gruff exterior he was a teddy bear.

I suspect as much about you all along!!

Editors are no longer the Lou Grant types (I was that kind of editor). They have a hole to fill, and they fill it with whatever the reporter turns in.
#39 | Posted by vernon

So you say reporters are lazy because editors let them get away with it?

So you say reporters are lazy because editors let them get away with it?

#41 | Posted by Hagbard_Celine at 2009-07-15 10:15 PM | Reply

That's part of it.

Journalists are no longer trained to do much original reporting. J-School often means you learn how to process press releases.

I never let my reporters get away with that. I trained them to cultivate sources and stay in touch with them, and find the real stories on their beats. My philosophy was that if someone was in the office, they were not doing their job. I wanted big expense claims each month: mileage, and they should take someone to lunch at least once a week.

Journalism school is also a waste. Reporting is not a profession but a trade, like plumbing, where you learn most of the job on the job.

My best reporters were English Lit majors -- they could think, and they could string words together. I could teach them the rest. History majors are also good because they understand how an event 20 years ago echoes today.

If you want to see how much of your news is canned by PR flacks all you have to do is read what's on AP and PR Newswire, and compare the content to your local paper.

The only original reporting that still happens is local sports.

I suspect as much about you all along!!

#40 | Posted by Lisa at 2009-07-15 10:14 PM | Reply

If my pregnant wife were not in the room right now I would kiss you Lisa.

LOL Vernon

You couldn't fool me!

I send you well wishes for you, your wife and your new baby! May he/she be born healthy!!

How far along is she?

Very true. It is Greek tragedy. A person of high standing or prosperity with a tragic flaw loses all.

Yeah, the only difference between our instinct and chimp instinct somedays is that we occasionally put people up on a pedestal before we fling feces at them.

Honestly, I wouldn't piss on 90% of hollywood (lowercase letters intended) if they were on fire next to me. I stopped caring about the movie industry when that fucking idiot made the movie redacted. That little leprechaun that owns the spurs can get a step ladder and kiss every inch of my white ass and I still wouldn't care for hollywood.

I don't watch tv so I didn't watch any of the Michael Jackson Drama play out. Al Sharpton wants MJ's picture on a stamp. What the hell? Are they going to put the words "It's ok kids, your parents said it's ok if you lick me" at the bottom of the stamp? Please!! All of the so-called celebrities came running at a chance to get free publicity and they are all coming out of the wood work to declare they were Michaels best friend. Honestly, I have higher standards for friends than that. If I'm going to have friends, they are going to be the kind of people that say nice things about me before I die.

I had a celebrity stand right next to me at 6 flags and I ignored them and they did go away. I don't worship these idiots like most of you lefties. I couldn't care less about them if I tried.

Lonnie

On a Tangental Note,

Do any of you listen to Jim Rome?

on his show yesterday he talked about having dinner with Kobe Bryant, the purpose of the dinner was that Kobe had called or e-mailed Jim stating that Kobe knew Jacko well and that the way that he was being portrayed was waay off base.

Acording to Rome, Bryant said that MJ was as driven, as focused, and as hungry to succeede as he had ever been with his previous work. He also stated that no one was more determined to achieve perfection in his profession than MJ was. (i have always thought that his early stuff is fantabulous, i got bored when he got preachy, but thats a matter of message not execution) and that he was looking forward to making more music.

In that light. It really is sad that he was surrounded by deranged psychophants (not to say he was all there when it came to medical stuff either) that let him get into the state he was in medicaly. We may have been robbed of another Thriller.

imagine--most if not all of these sycophants are Obama supporters...this is what you call a cataclysmic scenario-a perfect storm. Aeternum vale.

Brooke Shields and CalifChris reminded us that their was a human being somewhere inside the piece of property desperately trying to get out, but unable to.

Very true. It is Greek tragedy. A person of high standing or prosperity with a tragic flaw loses all.

Yeah, the only difference between our instinct and chimp instinct somedays is that we occasionally put people up on a pedestal before we fling feces at them.

It is not about mocking the tragic figure, not at all. We are fascinated by tragedy because we know it is inescapable in our own lives and that we are all victims at some time of both fate and our own choices. If anything we look on because a part of us identifies with him in a sense that we have all done stupid things that has lead to our own suffering.

To view a tragic life, therefore, is to provide, according to Aristotle, catharsis for our own fear and worry and anguish.

We are often our own worst enemies, and celebrities and people in power magnify this idea tremendously. They have gained all the things we strive for, fame, power and wealth, but will they be their own undoing?

The tragic figure that falls off the pedestal is more fascinating then because they represent both the height of our dreams and the depth of our fears all rolled into one.

Its also a little bit of schadenfreude.

So vermin gets one half right due to personal involvement: i.e. a useful idiot.

Truth:

"I deplore... the putrid state into which our newspapers have passed and the malignity, the vulgarity, and mendacious spirit of those who write for them... These ordures are rapidly depraving the public taste and lessening its relish for sound food. As vehicles of information and a curb on our funtionaries, they have rendered themselves useless by forfeiting all title to belief... This has, in a great degree, been produced by the violence and malignity of party spirit." --Thomas Jefferson to Walter Jones, 1814. ME 14:46

"Our printers raven on the agonies of their victims, as wolves do on the blood of the lamb." --Thomas Jefferson to James Monroe, 1811. ME 13:59

"From forty years' experience of the wretched guess-work of the newspapers of what is not done in open daylight, and of their falsehood even as to that, I rarely think them worth reading, and almost never worth notice." --Thomas Jefferson to James Monroe, 1816. ME 14:430

"Nothing can now be believed which is seen in a newspaper. Truth itself becomes suspicious by being put into that polluted vehicle. The real extent of this state of misinformation is known only to those who are in situations to confront facts within their knowledge with the lies of the day." --Thomas Jefferson to John Norvell, 1807. ME 11:224

"As for what is not true, you will always find abundance in the newspapers." --Thomas Jefferson to Barnabas Bidwell, 1806. ME 11:118

"Advertisements... contain the only truths to be relied on in a newspaper." --Thomas Jefferson to Nathaniel Macon, 1819. ME 15:179

"The press is impotent when it abandons itself to falsehood." --Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Seymour, 1807.

Freedom of press is limited to those who own one. -- mencken

Random thoughts on this subject

anyone who thinks there was some kind of journalistic integrity in a bygone era significantly stronger than one today is fooling themselves, during the 1800's the newspapers were primarily highly partisan periodicals that used far stronger biased rhethoric than today, lincoln the ape is an example.

a little over 100 years ago the media (in a strange parrallel to recent events) massaged the public and this nation into a war (sound familiar with the current echo chamber?)

the media gives us what we want, if we didnt want MJ 24/7 it wouldnt have given it to us. Concurrently, the media is so intertwined with big business and politics that they want us unlearned and celebrity obsessed because that makes their life easier by controlling what we know and understand about life and the world around us.

To be empowered the masses need will and knowledge. Knowledge of alternatives, of what is really going on, of possibilities. Will encompasses collective power and includes overcoming the malaise we are in.

We no longer have frontiers to push. We are a wealthy nation, wealthiest in the history of the world and for the vast majority of us we no longer have to worry about existance but the meaning of existence.

We are uneducated, we are selfish lacking empathy because we have had no real experience with need. We have lost the powerful frontier and innovative spirits because we have the power of the manifest destiny of our castle on the hill.

We need to learn history, to learn civics, to learn humility.

We have what we want now, but like the spoiled children we are we think it will last forever and we care not the cost it has on others.

There will be no change until the masses demand change. And that won't happen until we experience need. We are quite content in the status quo, though a subtle and unnameabl fear is building within us, fear of outsiders and fear of an uncertain future. We fear because we do not comprehend, we do not comprehend because we are willfully ignorant lack empathy for others.

But the dangers these fear touch upon are real and are in many ways of our own childish making. Greed, fear of others, selfishness, arrogance, hubris, delusion, fear of pain are all our collective problem.

There are outsiders. Some wish us harm, some wish us well. Often the two go hand in hand. We often choose confrontation to justify our fears and give our fears a direction to point to.

The future is uncertain, we are constantly adding to a bill that will come do at some point, probably in the not to distant future. We are incapable now of stopping or reversing this trend and we believe some magic will save us. But we are not preordained by any power to live without cost and without ramifications for our actions.

that bill when it comes will be harsh and severe, and will teach our nation what real need is. Hopefully at that point we will learn humility.

Moderation in all things, including moderation.

What does all this coverage and the following of say of us? That we are all going to HELL for breaking God's comandment "Thou shall not worship any other God before me".

I have not followed the coverage nor will I start to no matter how sensationalistic it may become.

Please save us all from the hype!!

How far along is she?

#44 | Posted by Lisa at 2009-07-16 12:41 AM | Reply |

Due date is September 17. It's a boy, and he's on schedule -- gradually turning to the head-down position

My wife is Filipina and we live in Taiwan, but he will be a U.S. Citizen. I want to get a tattoo on his foot that says 'Made in Taiwan' but my wife doesn't get the joke

i.e. a useful idiot.

#52 | Posted by Shawn at 2009-07-16 10:13 AM | Reply

from the loser with no discernible skills. And apparently no job that does not involve selling Squishies and Fried Pickles

bah. All you can do is spew sh%t vermin.

"I wanted big expense claims each month: mileage, and they should take someone to lunch at least once a week."

I actually appreciated your answer, vernon. Thank you. Lets not make a habit of that.

but the excerpt above speaks to part of my point, i.e. the quest for the bottom line in a corporate owned newspaper. Surely you accept that the days of big expense reports are through, and that their departure has its own effect on the quality of news today.

but the excerpt above speaks to part of my point, i.e. the quest for the bottom line in a corporate owned newspaper. Surely you accept that the days of big expense reports are through, and that their departure has its own effect on the quality of news today.

#59 | Posted by Hagbard_Celine at 2009-07-16 11:48 AM | Reply | Flag:

The news industry has experienced the dinosaur 'experience' in that the most talented people move on to other jobs. Those who remain are not concerned about being professionals: they only care about marking time for a pension.

So you end up with hapless editors, managing dimwit and lazy reporters. All the people with initiative have moved on to other things.

I personally moved on to my recruiting business. I have former reporters who now sell commercial real estate, sell medical products or they are teachers.

Very interesting article.. I just got around to reading it..

Much of my earlier career was spent traveling in South America and Mexico. I was at first appalled at the corruption that was such an integral part of that culture, but like many others doing business down there, at some point became calloused to it. A normal business environment, where a deal is a deal, is impossible in that type of culture.

Here's my take on it.. successful business climates require moral underpinnings... several of the nation's founders said the same thing.. in fact, going so far as to say that democracy requires it. And to irritate the politically correct devotees, they meant a Christian morality.. you can disagree with their viewpoint, but you can't disagree rationally with the history. They weren't perfect people by any means, and often didn't live up to their own ideals.. but that's not an argument against the ideals.

The idea that celebrity gives license for immoral behavior is becoming part of our culture. I don't think its all that new in the culture, rather, we just now live in an environment where its easier to communicate that idea.

It's basis is simply that there are no absolutes.. and once you philosophically cross that bridge, then the narcissism and other behaviors associated with celebrity become logical.

Its probably good for us to all examine ourselves a bit in that regard.

bah. All you can do is spew sh%t vermin.

#58 | Posted by Shawn at 2009-07-16 11:38 AM | Reply

Well said, Shawn. Brilliant!

You want fries with that?

What kind of hot sauce?

We have root beer Squishees today!

Ask me about our fried pickles!

What pump were you at?

#61 | Posted by nmg_no at 2009-07-16 12:27 PM | Reply | Flag: Failed American history.

No vermin. I wouldn't buy fries from you(don't want to catch something)...

"A newspaper is a device for making the ignorant more ignorant and the crazy crazier." H.L. Mencken

imagine what he would have said about tv or bloggers

CHILDREN ARE NOW SAFER. THANK GOD THIS FAG IS DEAD

Different strokes for different folks. This is the scenario that the mentality of a good percentage of the American people embraces. Many of them identify with matters affecting celebrities with more feeling than they do with matters affecting themselves or their families or friends.

Some of you folks sound puritanical and extremely judgemental elevating the benefits of thinking about some matters and experiencing certain feelings that preoccupy you above those that concern others.

On a very practical basis, during times of prosperity, this frittering away of time shows how far above a subsistance existence we are. We can use leisure time to think above exalted matters not germane to our daily existence. Nowadays other concerns concerning standard of living may intrude themselves.

He could dance. He had a falsetto contralto voice. He was troubled. Why do so many people experience the emotions they do concerning a person with whom they are not intimates, and whose departure will have only a fleeting and minimal effect on their lives.

Why are mattters some of you seem to consider "profound" so much more worthwhile deliberating than having a festive time? Jackson's death just provided an excuse for a party. And for an opportunity for some folks to cash in on his celebrity - from the media to those jackals trying to gain control of his estate.

Comments are closed for this entry.


Drudge Retort

Home | News | Comments | User Blogs | Nooner | Back Page | RSS Feed | RSS Spec | DMCA Compliance | Copyright 2012 World Readable