TOSSER:
Over here, any cop can stop you and ask for your ID.
I show them my ID and then it's off you go mate.
Takes half a minute, tops.
Why did this prick of a padre show them attitude?
NEVER give cops an attitude. Anyone who has had dogs for pets knows that cops are exactly like your German-Sheppard. They focus on your tone and how you are carrying yourself. If you are giving vague and evasive answers they will dig in deeper.
not in America.
i have put together the items necessary understand this here:
www.math.fsu.edu
look at the items:
at_Liberty.pdf
and,
Hibel v. Nevada
and do your further research from there, however there is plenty there for any American to be up to date of their "at Liberty" rights. in short: the police cannot demand your ID, nor must you answer them, and you cannot be punished for maintaining those rights.
you cannot be moved, except for pubic access (not far at all) and you cannot he detained but very briefly. once you are effectively blocked from leaving you ARE under arrest whether it has been stated or not... and to ARREST there must be evidence of a crime.
police often try to engage in consensual conversation and can ask you whatever they want, just like i can ask you now.
look up Ed Lawson on wikipedia and on YouTube, here is an African-American who alone went to Supreme Court and won, but see my own link.
the must be reasonable suspicion that a crime has been committed or is about to be --that must be articulable in court... it is NOT a hunch.
reasonable suspicion allows a Terry type frisk (common traffic stops are Terry). in such a frisk they can feel your outer clothing --they can search NOTHING... they are "feeling"for their own and public safety, e.g., a weapon. if they pull drugs out your pocket that is illegal and inadmissible..
beyond reasonable suspicion is Probable Cause, a higher standard than Reasonable Suspicion.. with Probable Cause (e.g., warrant) search may occur.
if you read my items i linked you will find the latest and the history of the Supreme Court on this issue. it is quite clear and it is the law of the land.
police routinely violate these rights and lawyers routinely make deals as if you were guilty of something.
STAND UP for your RIGHTS and the RIGHTS of others. serve on juries and acquit drug crimes for example. YOU are the ONLY law in the court room.
++++
i have recently been thinking this very issue: when they "get you" with a device, such as radar, you can go to court and ask the see the calibrations.
i am sure i just haven't researched this aspect and i totally am opposed to their detaining a person at traffic stop in order to bring a dog in... it is a search.
searches, where legal, must also be specific for place and what is sought.
now, these "road block" things have been legalized for SPECIFIC PURPOSES, not as dragnets for any and everything, but all the rules still apply.
http://www.iihs.org/laws/
checkpoints.html
here is good sight:
http://www.papersplease.org/
wp/