Over a month ago I have already read David J. Steward's expose on Mary Baxter and found it wanting. Without much ado, I simply will say that his handling of scripture is rigid and calculated simply to discredit Ms Baxter. I stand by Baxter.
It is unfortunate that many people, both believers and liberals, loosely and glibly use the term 'false prophet' to characterize anyone they dislike or anyone who has not been perfect in their sharing of scripture --- or in some cases, simply for diasagreeing on scripture passages.
One thing for sure: both Baxter and Steward agrees that hell is real.
So doctrinally and biblically , Baxter did not deviate from scripture. To give an example, Steward adheres to the dogma that ONCE SAVED ALWAYS SAVED. And with this rigid stand he faulted Baxter for sharing that an expreacher was in hell. (By this standard, I guess the apostate and expreacher Dan Barker, founder of Freedom From Religion who is going about insulting God and chastising followers of Christ will be going to heaven after he dies --- please google his name and see if God should should let him into heaven without repentance).
Once saved always saved is a dogma long debated and there are arguments on both sides with backing from scripture.
Although what Baxter shared are considered extra-biblical (different from non-biblical), they are consistent with the reality of hell, and should God in mercy reveal things humans cannot come to know in their own power, it is to His mercy that these are revealed for the benefit of some who will respond with sincerity --- I'm aware many liberals will not, and instead will dismiss or seek to discredit.
Jesus Himself revealed some aspect of hell in Luke 16 --- that hell is a place of torment, the memory and consciousness never fades, there is constant thirst, and hopelessless.
To those mockers, you have free-will on earth; you can be arrogant till your last breath; but once you pass the physical world, you do not have one iota of power to affect your destiny.
To those who have out of curiosity checked out the story of Mary Baxter and Bill Weise, know that these people are sincere God-fearing people and 'they did not invent these revelations'.
Again scripture can be twisted to attack anything, but if you have a sincere heart and without a default mind to attack anything that is Christian, I hope to see you all in heaven someday.